Hay vs Estar in Spanish: The Difference Students Always Confuse

Español en serio

Hay vs Estar in Spanish: The Difference Students Always Confuse

Dieser Beitrag erklärt ein wichtiges Thema der spanischen Grammatik (Text auf Englisch).


A common confusion: hay or está?

Many students confuse the form hay (from the verb haber) and the form está (from the verb estar), which are two clearly different things. The form hay expresses existence, while the form está expresses location. Examples:

🟢 Hay un parque.
There is a park.
🟢 El parque está cerca de mi casa.
The park is close to my house.

If I say “hay un parque”, I am saying that “a park exists”, but when I say “el parque está cerca de mi casa”, I am specifying its location. However, sometimes we say something like this:

🟢 Hay un parque cerca de mi casa.
There is a park close to my house.

In reality, what we are saying is:

🟢 Hay un parque que está cerca de mi casa.
There is a park that is close to my house.

Now let’s look at another aspect. In English, we differentiate singular and plural. Examples:

There is a park. There are two parks.

Some languages, such as Spanish, French and German, use the same verb form in singular and plural in these cases:

Inglés
Español
Francés
Alemán
There is a park
Hay un parque
Il y a un parc
Es gibt einen Park
There are two parks
Hay dos parques
Il y a deux parcs
Es gibt zwei Parks

This creates errors, especially in the past and in the future, because English-speaking students tend to think that there must be a plural. Examples:

There was a park
Había un parque
There were two parks
Había dos parques (y no habían)
There will be a park
Habrá un parque
There will be two parks
Habrá dos parques (y no habrán)

If you are learning Spanish and find explanations like this helpful, I offer personalised online Spanish lessons for students and adults worldwide, including GCSE and A-Level preparation.
Lessons are available in English or German, and I offer a free initial consultation. You can contact me at laura@spanishforlondon.com.

Example from the episode

Remember that you can read the novel that complements this blog, which I am writing alongside these grammar posts, where you can see examples in context of what we are explaining:

→ “Están en una pizzería en Brighton”.

Read the full episode here →

Episode 24


Book your first free demo lesson, with no obligation on your behalf, at laura@spanishforlondon.com.

About your teacher
Bachelor’s degree in Literature (University of Buenos Aires). Spanish and Literature teacher. Researcher and author of Los premios Nobel de literatura. Una lectura crítica (University of Seville). More than 30 years’ experience teaching Spanish to international students.
One-to-one lessons via Zoom.

Über die Lehrerin
Abschluss in Literaturwissenschaft (Universität Buenos Aires). Lehrerin für Spanisch und Literatur. Forscherin und Autorin des Buches Los premios Nobel de literatura. Una lectura crítica (Universität Sevilla). Über 30 Jahre Erfahrung im Unterricht von Spanisch als Fremdsprache.
Einzelunterricht über Zoom.

Leave a Reply

two + 5 =